If the sound plays but the picture is black, audio decoding is working but the video stream may not be decoding or rendering correctly.
Confirm what is failing
Try the same file in MPC-HC and another player. If it displays correctly in one player, compare their decoding and video-output paths rather than assuming the file is broken.
Open the file in Media File Inspector to identify the actual video codec, profile and bit depth. MP4 or MKV alone does not identify the decoder needed.
Check decoding and video output
In MPC-HC, try a different video renderer or temporarily disable hardware-accelerated decoding as a diagnostic test. Restart playback after changing the setting.
If the video uses HEVC, AV1 or another newer codec, verify that the GPU supports that codec and profile. Software decoding may work when hardware decoding does not.
If the file remains black
Try a second known-good file with the same codec. If only one file fails, damaged video data or an unusual stream configuration may be responsible.
MPC-FFmpeg, available in the Plus edition, offers an alternative decoding path for compatible video files. It is not a video repair utility.